Deciding whether to sell your coins at a coin shop or on eBay depends on your goals. If you want quick cash and a hassle-free process, a local coin shop is the way to go.
You'll get an immediate offer without needing to list, photograph, or ship anything. However, dealers typically pay around 60–80% of a coin’s market value since they need to make a profit on resale.
On the other hand, selling on eBay offers a chance to reach millions of potential buyers. This often means higher prices, especially for rare or in-demand coins
You control your pricing and presentation, which can drive up the final sale. But eBay comes with fees, shipping responsibilities, and possible buyer disputes
It also takes more time and effort to manage listings and ensure smooth transactions.
If you're selling a few rare coins, eBay might get you top dollar. If you're offloading a large number of common coins or need money fast, a coin shop might be better.
For the best results, consider selling your high-value pieces online and taking the rest to a trusted local dealer. This hybrid approach maximizes profit while saving time. Choose based on what you value more: time or money.